Post History

66%

+2 −0

Meta Are economic speculation questions on-topic?

I once had a question Somewhere Else about an economic stipulation and how its imposition would affect the world. I didn't think it to be a good stipulation and expected to be skewered by answers p...

1 answer · posted 2mo ago by Michael‭ · edited 2mo ago by Canina‭

Question discussion site-definition

#3: Post edited by

Canina‭ · 2024-09-07T08:49:02Z (about 2 months ago)
Delete no-longer-referenced footnote

Copy Link

Raw

Markdown

I once had a question Somewhere Else about an economic stipulation and how its imposition would affect the world. I didn't think it to be a *good* stipulation and expected to be skewered by answers pointing out huge loopholes. But instead the question was closed.
~~Rather than repeat the experience naïvely: Is economics "scientific" enough for this community?~~
~~[^1]: Also someone wrote a negative comment about Americans, which in retrospect, I should have flagged as inappropriate.~~

I once had a question Somewhere Else about an economic stipulation and how its imposition would affect the world. I didn't think it to be a *good* stipulation and expected to be skewered by answers pointing out huge loopholes. But instead the question was closed.
Rather than repeat the experience naïvely: Is economics "scientific" enough for this community?

#2: Post edited by

Michael‭ · 2024-09-06T13:18:19Z (about 2 months ago)
Wipe the aside

Copy Link

Raw

Markdown

I once had a question Somewhere Else about an economic stipulation and how its imposition would affect the world. I didn't think it to be a *good* stipulation and expected to be skewered by answers pointing out huge loopholes. But instead the question was closed.[^1]
Rather than repeat the experience naïvely: Is economics "scientific" enough for this community?
[^1]: Also someone wrote a negative comment about Americans, which in retrospect, I should have flagged as inappropriate.

I once had a question Somewhere Else about an economic stipulation and how its imposition would affect the world. I didn't think it to be a *good* stipulation and expected to be skewered by answers pointing out huge loopholes. But instead the question was closed.
Rather than repeat the experience naïvely: Is economics "scientific" enough for this community?
[^1]: Also someone wrote a negative comment about Americans, which in retrospect, I should have flagged as inappropriate.

#1: Initial revision by

Michael‭ · 2024-09-05T21:33:27Z (about 2 months ago)

Copy Link

Raw

Markdown

Are economic speculation questions on-topic?

I once had a question Somewhere Else about an economic stipulation and how its imposition would affect the world. I didn't think it to be a *good* stipulation and expected to be skewered by answers pointing out huge loopholes. But instead the question was closed.[^1]

Rather than repeat the experience na&iuml;vely: Is economics "scientific" enough for this community?

[^1]: Also someone wrote a negative comment about Americans, which in retrospect, I should have flagged as inappropriate.

discussion site-definition

Communities

Post History